“Almost Zero Information”: Data Centers and Their Discontents

“Almost Zero Information”: Data Centers and Their Discontents
El interior de un centro de datos suizo. Foto de Florian Hirzinger/Wikimedia Commons

The frantic race to develop more powerful forms of AI has given rise to another race: a scramble to set up ever more data centers.

According to the Data Center Map, an online resource, there are currently 4,400 data centers in the United States. California is home to 292 of them and three of them—Lumen Fresno 1, Lumen Fresno 2 and Unwired FAT1—are located here in Fresno.

The operation of data centers isn’t without its problems and critics. Consider their voracious consumption of water and electricity, costs to public health and ongoing need for GPUs.

Water

In early July The Guardian reported that, according to a study by the Environmental and Energy Study Institute, an average data center requires 300,000 gallons of water every day for cooling and it’s been estimated that larger sites need five million gallons of water every day. 

Some observers note that such an appetite for water can be especially worrisome in areas that are prone to drought.

In May CalMatters examined the findings of another report by the Next 10 think tank and scholars at Santa Clara University. That study finds that such sites “are spreading to regions reliant on overtapped groundwater and strained surface water, with potentially major effects in the Central and Imperial Valleys.”

One difficulty that researchers in this area are facing: a mosaic of local, state and federal policies that allows data centers to conceal the amount of water that they use.

Last year Democratic Assemblymember Diane Papan put together a bill that would have required data centers to share their estimated or actual water use with their water supplier whenever they try to get or renew a permit or a business license.

Governor Gavin Newsom, however, bowed to industry forces and vetoed the bill, saying that he didn’t want to support such reporting requirements without knowing how such a mandate would affect the companies involved and their clients.

Electricity

A separate report by the Next 10 group and a UC Riverside researcher tackled the issue of data centers’ use of electricity, as reported in CalMatters last November. 

Given the sector’s lack of transparency, the authors cautioned that their numbers were just estimates. Shaolei Ren, one of the writers, commented that “We are just making these reports pretty much in the dark—since there’s almost zero information.”

The researchers determined that data centers in California likely used 10.8 terawatt-hours of electricity in 2023, a jump from 5.5 terawatt-hours four years earlier. Given the industry’s current growth trajectory, they project that demand could go up to as much as 25 terawatt-hours in two years—the equivalent of the amount of power used by about 2.4 million U.S. households.

Data centers, they argue, should be required to share their water and electricity use with the public and they need to adhere to uniform reporting protocols.

Health Costs

In the same report the authors also estimated that the public health costs from air pollution tied to data centers have risen sharply—from $45 million in 2019 to over $155 million in 2023. That impact on citizens’ health could rise to as much as $266 million during the next two years.

Much of this comes from indirect pollution produced by fossil-fueled power plants that serve the state’s grid. The report points out, however, that areas with many data centers, such as Santa Clara County, might well encounter greater risks due to diesel backup generators.

Chip Production

In addition, as Cory Doctorow notes in his latest book, The Reverse Centaur’s Guide to Life After AI, the need to replace graphics processing units, or GPUs, causes a significant amount of pollution on another level.

The GPUs that data centers often use don’t tend to last very long. While training its Llama model over 53 days, for example, Meta discovered that over half of its GPUs conked out and needed to be replaced. 

Just like data centers, plants that manufacture GPUs need huge amounts of water and energy and one byproduct of the production process is “the emission of toxic sludge.”

The lack of transparency regarding water and energy consumption seems to be part of a pattern in the industry’s behavior.

Industry observers note that when companies try to build new facilities, they often do so without saying which tech companies will use them. According to the Virginia Mercury, researchers have determined that among 31 Virginia locales with existing, approved, or proposed data centers, 80% had non-disclosure agreements with the firms behind the projects.

In some parts of the U.S. citizen groups are now demanding changes in the way that these sites are built and operated.

Earlier this year, activists in California, Florida, Michigan, Missouri, Oklahoma, Oregon and Texas have attempted to recall elected officials because of the way they dealt with data center projects.

For her part, Assemblymember Papan is now proposing two new bills. The first resembles the one that she crafted in 2025, though it now also includes reporting requirements for cities and counties.

Her second bill would prevent local governments from green-lighting new or expanded data centers unless the developers provide details about their water use and plans. It would also introduce further requirements—for example, it would block development in overdrafted groundwater regions such as the San Joaquin Valley unless state water managers sign off on it.

F. Noel Perry, who founded the Next 10 think tank, argues that the rapid growth of data centers worldwide involves significant environmental costs. For him it’s vital to mandate transparent practices in this sector. Doing so would give regulators and elected officials the opportunity to effectively oversee data center operations in the public interest.

Clearly, far more than “almost zero information” is needed to make that happen. 

Author

  • Steven Roesch

    Steven Roesch is a retired German and English teacher who taught in the Fresno Unified School District for 30 years. Contact him at stevenroesch12@comcast.net.

    View all posts
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x